I have blogged about the year I spent gaining my Masters degree in comprehensive detail (mostly here and here). However I never wrote any summary or reflection on the whole experience. So being asked to speak at the recent SIFII REAP Seminar on Professional Postgraduate Programmes gave me the incentive to put some thoughts in order two years after the fact.
One benefit of a fifteen-minute speaking slot is that I was forced to be concise. So this palimpsest of a more thorough retrospective may be of interest to anyone who is weighing the options of taking on a part-time MA and maintaining a professional career at the same time.
Showing posts with label dissertation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dissertation. Show all posts
Monday, May 30, 2011
Monday, June 15, 2009
Five Years Blogging
This blog is five years old today. At some point it would be interesting (to me) to look back over the history of this blog and review how its content and direction have evolved over that time. Although this previous year has been somewhat exceptional. For most of the time since last September I have been writing in a closed-access private secondary blog, as I have been concentrating on writing material for my MA programme. I have cross-posted some of that content here so that this blog does not lie fallow for the twelve-month duration of the course.
At present I am working on my MA dissertation,which now has its own dedicated blog as well. That third blog is freely accessible. As most of my time has been spent so far on researching and drafting literature reviews there is not as much content on that blog as I would like. Now as I move into the later stages of my dissertation project and more material is finalised you should see more content populating the pages there.
As part of my research I am collating a list of Irish graphic design blogs which will reside on a dedicated page within that site. I am currently processing and analysing the list, but a subset of the total are already in place there. Any comments and feedback on the content of that site are welcome, everything gets added into my research. If you are aware of any Irish graphic design blogs please let me know so that I can include them as well.
Update
I have now closed my dedicated dissertation blog and republished all of its contents within this Thoughtport blog. I have tagged my primary research posts with ‘Masters_PDP’ and ‘Irish Blog Research’. Secondary sources, videos and other resources gathered during my research process are tagged with Dissertation Assets.
At present I am working on my MA dissertation,
As part of my research I am collating a list of Irish graphic design blogs
Update
I have now closed my dedicated dissertation blog and republished all of its contents within this Thoughtport blog. I have tagged my primary research posts with ‘Masters_PDP’ and ‘Irish Blog Research’. Secondary sources, videos and other resources gathered during my research process are tagged with Dissertation Assets.
Monday, May 18, 2009
Ubiquitous Capture
Another key learning from this process of researching and composing my MA dissertation has been a rediscovery of the centrality of ‘Ubiquitous Capture’ as a behaviour. This is a core practice of the GTD methodology, and one I am mostly in the habit of observing. But given the amount of work to be done on this dissertation and the time scale involved I have gained a new appreciation for its utility. Whether it was on my daily commutes, lunch breaks, or sitting in the car with a sleeping baby in the back seat, all opportune thoughts, ideas, and insights went into the Notes app on my iPod , or were jotted into one of many small black notebooks as they occurred to me.
Even as the majority of these notes were heavily revised or simply abandoned, the importance of recording all such relevant thoughts as they occur made the task of actual composition far more efficient. Being able to start with some raw materials ready for crafting and refining means that I always have something to work on for those days when my mind was unprepared to tackle an intimidating blank page.
Thinking that your brain works on any project only during its allocated time is a self-defeating fallacy, one that this practice routes around. Helpful as this practice was in marshaling all of my thoughts for this dissertation, it really is a critical life skill with broad application to all projects.
Even as the majority of these notes were heavily revised or simply abandoned, the importance of recording all such relevant thoughts as they occur made the task of actual composition far more efficient. Being able to start with some raw materials ready for crafting and refining means that I always have something to work on for those days when my mind was unprepared to tackle an intimidating blank page.
Thinking that your brain works on any project only during its allocated time is a self-defeating fallacy, one that this practice routes around. Helpful as this practice was in marshaling all of my thoughts for this dissertation, it really is a critical life skill with broad application to all projects.
Saturday, May 16, 2009
The Necessity of the Analogue
One of the more interesting personal learnings from this project is a rediscovery of what I have come to call ‘the necessity of the analogue’. After spending time constructing a moderately elaborate, robust infrastructure of online services to support my research and writing, I found myself writing many of my key insights and findings in black ink in small notebooks.
One detrimental aspect of researching blogging is that there is a practically infinite buffet of blog-related news always available no more than one distracted mouse-click away. I found that writing on the laptop affords far too many distractions. Typing is not a problem, but I have done the majority of my most effective thinking, analysing and writing off-line.
A blank page is a blank page affording only opportunities — not endless distractions.
One detrimental aspect of researching blogging is that there is a practically infinite buffet of blog-related news always available no more than one distracted mouse-click away. I found that writing on the laptop affords far too many distractions. Typing is not a problem, but I have done the majority of my most effective thinking, analysing and writing off-line.
A blank page is a blank page affording only opportunities — not endless distractions.
Friday, May 15, 2009
Twitter as a Research Asset
Given that the key books that I am referencing all happen to have been published around 2006, it seems useful to follow up on the author’s activities in 2009. I reason that, in evolving, fast-moving, early-stage activities like blogging and social media, any expert’s thinking should have evolved significantly as they incorporate the last three year’s worth of developments.
I found that all of the key authors had active current blogs. Keeping up with those within my work-flow and time commitments proved problematic. Of much more utility was that all of them also had active Twitter accounts. This meant that every day, as part of the casual act of reading my Twitter-feed, I was continually being made aware of further useful material pertinent to my research. Most of the author’s tweets pointed to both their own blog posts and to relevant thoughts and analysis they had sourced online. While the majority of my research has to be ‘pull-based’ – with me going out looking for material, this added a ‘push’ dimension – with content being directed towards me.
One downside to this methodology is that, once following enough experts in your field of interest, you may become overwhelmed with the fire-hose of content pointed at you. This can be mitigated by developing good personal content filters and ruthlessly unfollowing anyone whose tweets are not adding value to your research.
I have found this practice very beneficial in the information gathering phases of my MA research. It is a most effective way of keeping abreast by scanning and evaluating a high volume of potential material. I would recommend this to any researcher, particularly those whose topic concerns technology or Internet-related subjects.
I found that all of the key authors had active current blogs. Keeping up with those within my work-flow and time commitments proved problematic. Of much more utility was that all of them also had active Twitter accounts. This meant that every day, as part of the casual act of reading my Twitter-feed, I was continually being made aware of further useful material pertinent to my research. Most of the author’s tweets pointed to both their own blog posts and to relevant thoughts and analysis they had sourced online. While the majority of my research has to be ‘pull-based’ – with me going out looking for material, this added a ‘push’ dimension – with content being directed towards me.
One downside to this methodology is that, once following enough experts in your field of interest, you may become overwhelmed with the fire-hose of content pointed at you. This can be mitigated by developing good personal content filters and ruthlessly unfollowing anyone whose tweets are not adding value to your research.
I have found this practice very beneficial in the information gathering phases of my MA research. It is a most effective way of keeping abreast by scanning and evaluating a high volume of potential material. I would recommend this to any researcher, particularly those whose topic concerns technology or Internet-related subjects.
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
My Thought for the Day 22/04/09
“Trying to work out the correct formatting construction for citing tweets in my dissertation. A First World problem or what?”
9:24 PM Apr 22nd from my Twitterfeed.
9:24 PM Apr 22nd from my Twitterfeed.
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Establishing a Dissertation Blog
Social media and technology journalist, author, and blogger, Shel Israel is writing a book on the intersection of Twitter and business called Twitterville, due for publication in the third quarter of 2009. He is blogging the writing process, putting up his raw notes and interviews. He is crowd-sourcing comments, feedback and suggestions to further his research (but holding back his final manuscript for publication obviously).
This approach would be a productive model for an aspect my own research. It certainly puts the traits of openness and transparency into practice: “be the change you wish to see”. In my case I have created a dedicated dissertation Work-In-Progress blog as my public research and crowd-source hub.
Update
Following the completion of my MA programme I have retired my dedicated dissertation blog and merged all of its content into this Thoughtport blog.
This approach would be a productive model for an aspect my own research. It certainly puts the traits of openness and transparency into practice: “be the change you wish to see”. In my case I have created a dedicated dissertation Work-In-Progress blog as my public research and crowd-source hub.
Update
Following the completion of my MA programme I have retired my dedicated dissertation blog and merged all of its content into this Thoughtport blog.
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
My Thought for the Day 15/04/09
“Writing Literature Review long-hand. My theory was that after 40-odd pages my writing would improve with practice. Sigh. So much for that...”
11:54 PM Apr 15th from my Twitterfeed.
11:54 PM Apr 15th from my Twitterfeed.
Wednesday, April 01, 2009
My Thought for the Day 01/04/09
“Hmmm, perhaps my Twitter-referencing April Fools gag was just too clever-clever by half...”
10:52 PM Apr 1st from twitterrific
10:52 PM Apr 1st from twitterrific
Thursday, March 26, 2009
My Thought for the Day 26/03/09
“3K+ words written, now I need to get the train into college library, but it is really lashing rain. Therefore: Motivation Level = Low.”
2:25 PM Mar 26th from Power Twitter
2:25 PM Mar 26th from Power Twitter
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Cutting Through the Dissertation Fog
I am trying to tie down my Dissertation Research Question in detail and that is still proving to be somewhat of a challenge. I imagine that it is the absolute cliché of the MA student that one finds more and more interesting avenues of investigation the more more reading and researching one conducts. My initial research this last week has shown me that.
I now have a very clear sense of why a defined and locked-down trinity of Question, Aims and Objectives can serve as a necessary merciless filter for keeping laser-focus on the end-goals of my Dissertation.
I now have a very clear sense of why a defined and locked-down trinity of Question, Aims and Objectives can serve as a necessary merciless filter for keeping laser-focus on the end-goals of my Dissertation.
Sunday, March 22, 2009
My Thought for the Day 22/03/09
“Doing some initial online research into corporate blogging. Oh yessiree that’s one fine can of worms you have opened up there Mr Kenny...”9:31 PM Mar 22nd from Power Twitter
Thursday, March 19, 2009
My Thought for the Day 19/03/09
“Attempting to construct an irrefutable wall of logic: each component self-evident, elegantly reinforced & interdependant. (Not quite there.)”11:23 PM Mar 19th from twitterrific
Friday, March 13, 2009
My Thought for the Day 13/03/09
“Social Media defined: the most efficient method yet devised to allow companies to show the world that they hire people who cannot spell.”
08:22 AM March 13, 2009, from my Twitter feed.
08:22 AM March 13, 2009, from my Twitter feed.
Sunday, March 01, 2009
Quote of the Day 01/03/09
“To get your ideas across, use small words, big ideas, and short sentences.”
—John H Patterson
—John H Patterson
Monday, February 23, 2009
Drafting My Thesis Proposal
I spent time today assembling my thesis proposal so that I have it in better shape for my meeting with John O’Connor tomorrow.
What is interesting is discovering that something I thought I had a clear idea about is really only a loosely-related cloudy collection of notions. Working through the proposal headings to break my topic down into its logical components and arguments is more interesting and rewarding than I had envisaged. The challenge is to really question all of my assumptions as I go.
Even at this very initial stage what I am finding is that as I think through the questions posed under each heading, I am splintering off sub-questions and sub-issues that all seem worthwhile pursuing. I have read so much about this topic over the last number of years that I have a menagerie of relevant ideas, opinions, commentary and analysis in my head. Different aspects of which keep surfacing as related points and issues are re-encountered in the drafting process.
I had a draft prepared for tomorrows meeting then I read Louise’s feedback on two topics posted by some of the others on WebCourses. That inspired me to go back in and immediately edit out some of the material I had been unsure about. So I think today’s draft is now about 50% focused. If I can get to the core of my proposal with John tomorrow and discard the rest of the extraneous material that will be most productive.
What is interesting is discovering that something I thought I had a clear idea about is really only a loosely-related cloudy collection of notions. Working through the proposal headings to break my topic down into its logical components and arguments is more interesting and rewarding than I had envisaged. The challenge is to really question all of my assumptions as I go.
Even at this very initial stage what I am finding is that as I think through the questions posed under each heading, I am splintering off sub-questions and sub-issues that all seem worthwhile pursuing. I have read so much about this topic over the last number of years that I have a menagerie of relevant ideas, opinions, commentary and analysis in my head. Different aspects of which keep surfacing as related points and issues are re-encountered in the drafting process.
I had a draft prepared for tomorrows meeting then I read Louise’s feedback on two topics posted by some of the others on WebCourses. That inspired me to go back in and immediately edit out some of the material I had been unsure about. So I think today’s draft is now about 50% focused. If I can get to the core of my proposal with John tomorrow and discard the rest of the extraneous material that will be most productive.
Monday, February 16, 2009
Quote of the Day 16/02/09
“So there is no such thing as information overload, there’s only filter failure.”
—Clay Shirkey, Interview with Columbia Journalism Review.
—Clay Shirkey, Interview with Columbia Journalism Review.
Friday, February 13, 2009
My Thought for the Day 13/02/09
“Moving the icons around on my iPod so that all dissertation-related apps are on same screen. That does count as productive work, yes?”
8:59 February 13, 2009, from my Twitter feed.
8:59 February 13, 2009, from my Twitter feed.
Monday, January 12, 2009
Friday, January 09, 2009
Quote Of The Day 09/01
“Twitter: Writing or sharing cool stuff. Builds respect. Grants acceptance from others to self-promote = Profit!”
—Hugh MacLeod. From his Twitter feed.
—Hugh MacLeod. From his Twitter feed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)